The school uniform debate has been going on for years. Almost everyone involved in education (parents, teachers, school officials, students) usually has an opinion about the issue. Increasingly, more districts in Florida want to enforce school uniform policies, so if you are seeking an educational leadership master's degree, this debate is a topic you should prepare for.
School uniforms: the pros
School uniforms provide some benefits to teachers, students and parents. For teachers, uniforms can eliminate some distraction the classroom. Teachers face a number of challenges in the classroom: limiting the use of smartphones, ensuring students turn in homework, dealing with student absences and trying to engage students in learning. The school uniform debate acknowledges that clothing can become a distraction, especially if a student lacks the money for the latest fashion trends. Uniforms prevent students from worrying about who is wearing what, whether leggings are considered pants, and buying the best jeans — because everyone would have the same options: collared shirts and slacks or skirts.
School uniforms can also make dressing in the morning easier for students and parents: no more getting to school late because the student had a hard time choosing the perfect outfit for picture day. Administrators in schools that have already implemented this policy have noticed a drop in absences and trips to the school office for dress code violations. Additionally, school uniforms can make students feel more connected with one another because they are all dressed similarly.
School uniforms also benefit parents. Uniforms are less expensive than an entire wardrobe: parents would only need to purchase a few articles of clothing each year. In a school without uniforms, parents may feel pressured to buy their kids a new wardrobe for school every year, which is not always affordable.
School uniforms: the cons
With all the pros of the school uniform debate come many cons. One aspect that some parents disagree with is that districts receive monetary incentives for implementing this policy. Some districts could get up to $10 a child for making their schools adopt uniforms. Some parents disagree with this incentive and believe that money should be put into teachers' hands instead to improve their lessons and classrooms.
Further, many teachers and parents feel students should express themselves by choosing what they wear. During elementary and middle school years when uniforms are most predominant, students are changing and developing rapidly. This time is when they may feel most creative, and uniforms can hinder their self-expression. Some parents also argue that the benefits of school uniforms, such as reducing bullying and increasing productivity, have not been proven. Anecdotal evidence from some Florida schools that require uniforms shows some benefits, but it is difficult to predict whether a different school district would see the same results.
The school uniform debate is still ongoing, and both sides of the argument are valid. Teachers in traditional public schools tend to lean to the pro-uniform side since it may reduce bullying and teasing during the tumultuous adolescent years. Many districts are leaving the decision up to the schools themselves, and school administrators will probably hear complaints from parents no matter what they choose. However, if the benefits outweigh the pushback from students and parents, it might be in the interest of schools to consider this policy.
Learn more about the UWF M.Ed. in Educational Leadership Certification online program.
Have a question or concern about this article? Please contact us.